Academic Journal
On the division of labor in the maintenance of intersubjectivity: insights from the study of other-initiated repair in Vietnamese.
| Taitara: | On the division of labor in the maintenance of intersubjectivity: insights from the study of other-initiated repair in Vietnamese. |
|---|---|
| Ngā kaituhi: | Sidnell, Jack, Huong Thị Thanh Vũ |
| Puna: | Frontiers in Sociology; 2024, p01-17, 17p |
| Whakarāpopotonga: | Few ideas have figured more centrally in the history of social theory than that of the division of labor. Here we ask whether conversational interaction, like other forms of social activity, exhibits a division of labor and, if so, what functions this serves and how it might be understood in relation to the theories of Marx and Durkheim. We begin by noting that, though conversational participants actively work to achieve and sustain understanding, much of the time this work is invisible and only its products are displayed in the form of sequentially fitted next turns at talk. However, in sequences of other-initiated repair, the work involved in the maintenance of intersubjectivity rises to the surface. On these occasions, we can see and thus describe what participants do to achieve and sustain what they take to be adequate understanding. In our data, which consist of video recordings of casual conversations among Vietnamese same-generation peers, participants continuously display an orientation to relations of relative seniority through the selection of terms used to accomplish interlocutor reference. This pervasive orientation is also reflected in practices of repair initiation. Specifically, seniors regularly initiate repair with so-called "open class" forms such as "huh?" and "ha?" which display a minimal grasp of the talk targeted, require little effort to produce and, at the same time, push responsibility for resolving the problem onto the trouble source speaker (i.e., the junior member of the dyad). In contrast, juniors often initiate repair of a senior participant's talk by displaying a detailed understanding of what has been said, either in the form of a repeat or a reformulation, and inviting the senior to confirm. We suggest then that this asymmetry in the distribution of initiation practices reflects a "division of intersubjective labor". We conclude with some thoughts on the theoretical implications of our findings and relate them not only to the theories of Marx and Durkheimbut also to the writings of feminist sociolinguists who sought to describe the way in which women seemto be burdenedmore thanmen with what Fishman called "interactional shitwork." [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR] |
| Ngā kupu marau: | DIVISION of labor, VIETNAMESE language, INTERSUBJECTIVITY, SOCIAL theory, SOCIAL history, FEMINIST criticism, FORCED labor |
| People: | MARX, Karl, 1818-1883 |
| Copyright of Frontiers in Sociology is the property of Frontiers Media S.A. and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. This abstract may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy. Users should refer to the original published version of the material for the full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts.) | |
| ISSN: | 22977775 |
| DOI: | 10.3389/fsoc.2023.1205433 |
| Pātengi raraunga: | Complementary Index |
Wāteatanga